The Somber Polly Jean…
PJ Harvey White Chalk Island Released 10.2.07 Rating: 8 out of 10 I hate to say that it summarizes the album, but it is very telling that White Chalk , latest offering from Mizz Polly Jean Harvey , has a song in it called “The Piano.” Shaping the overall tone and especially the mood, the piano is indeed the vehicle by which Harvey expresses herself and reveals…well, it’s almost like she’s never sung before now. That’s not to say that Harvey’s past work doesn’t compare, or that she’s never sung a powerful note: none of that would be true. But, with White Chalk , you realize what KIND of singing she’s capable of as she exudes this childlike voice that’s worn life’s tragedies and reflected on its own perhaps uncertain existence. Emanating from that characteristically self-assured, charismatic rocker throat, I had to check a couple times to whom I was listening, because it doesn’t sound like Polly Jean. Critics have applied the word “departure” to White Chalk like a cheap s